2019 Nissan Frontier vs. Toyota Tacoma: Best Small Truck Comparison

Smaller pickup trucks, like the new Nissan Frontier and Toyota Tacoma, are all the rage these days, as shoppers are finally jumping on the bandwagon. We don’t blame them. The Tacoma and Frontier are incredibly versatile, do-it-all vehicles, offering SUV-like utility that even diehard truck purists can’t argue with. Best of all, you don’t need to hand over a Scrooge McDuck-sized bag of gold to buy one.

2019 Nissan Frontier vs Toyota Tacoma

Which of these highly rated pickups is best? Which truck is the cheapest? Which one offers more space? Let’s compare specs and features so you can make a wise decision at the truck dealership.

Best Price: Nissan Frontier

It’s more practical to grab the keys to a Nissan Frontier if you’re looking to buy a new truck on a budget.

The 2019 Frontier is the cheapest truck in price, as the Frontier S model can be had for $19k, while the base Toyota Tacoma starts at over $25,000. With the extra $6,000 in savings, you could even bump up to an upgraded Nissan Frontier SV with a V6, satellite radio, a sunroof, sliding bed extender, spray-on bedliner, dual-zone climate, heated seats, and an automatic-dimming rearview mirror.

At the top of the trucks’ off-roading lineup – the Nissan Frontier PRO-4X® vs. Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro – price differences are even more apparent. The Frontier PRO-4X has an MSRP of $33,530 while the Tacoma TRD Pro has a starting price of nearly $43,000. A $10k difference is quite substantial, especially considering the trucks’ similar range-topping, off-road features, like thick skid plates, Bilstein® shocks, and electronically locking rear differentials.

Better Fuel Efficiency: Tie

On the gas-guzzling front, the Frontier and Tacoma are similar. Returning 19 mpg in the city and 23 mpg on the highway, the Nissan Frontier is slightly more fuel-efficient than the Tacoma (18 city/22 hwy mpg). A gallon of gas saved here and there would certainly be enough for an extra night on the town.

Cheapest Small Truck

Features: Nissan Frontier

Most people don’t buy trucks for the creature comforts, which is why automakers like Toyota and Nissan don’t make trucks with tons of amenities. However, the Frontier and Tacoma do differ a bit in this department.

For instance, the 2019 Nissan Frontier includes a few features that the Tacoma doesn’t, such as an 8-way power-adjustable driver’s seat, 4-way power-adjustable passenger seat, the Utili-track® Channel System with 4 adjustable tie-downs, heated front seats and seatbacks, fully automatic lights with delay-off functionality, headlight washer, heated side mirrors, and a 10-speaker sound system with amplifier.

The Tacoma isn’t without its list of exclusive features, however. When comparing the Tacoma Limited to the Frontier SL, the Toyota truck includes the following: Smart key/proximity key, 2 LCD display screens, daytime running lights, LED brake lights, and a handful of advanced safety technologies.

More Space: Nissan Frontier

With regards to front space, both the Tacoma and Frontier are comparable, with the Tacoma narrowly besting the Frontier in front hip room (57.2 inches to 55.8 inches).

However, rear passengers will feel more comfortable in the Nissan Frontier. Headroom, legroom, and hip room come in at 36.6 inches, 25.4 inches, and 55 inches, respectively. The Toyota Tacoma provides 34.9 inches of rear headroom, 24.6 inches of rear legroom, and just 51.7 inches of rear hip room.

The Frontier also has a cargo box that’s a bit more accommodating. Its floor width maxes out at 61.4 inches, beating the Tacoma’s 56.7-inch width.

Nissan Frontier Towing

Max 4-Cylinder Towing: Nissan Frontier

As you likely know, trailering capacity is an important spec to look at when you’re choosing a truck. With the Frontier’s standard 4-cylinder – a 2.5L DOHC 16-valve 4-churner – you can tow a max of 3,810 lbs (SV King Cab model). That’s more than the standard 3,500-pound towing limit on the 4-cylinder Toyota Tacoma S. And when you get into V6 territory, the Frontier is just 110 pounds shy of matching the Tacoma’s 6,800-lb. towing capacity.

Get a Great Deal on the 2019 Frontier Before 2020!

The Nissan Frontier is expected to be fully redesigned for the 2020 model year. To celebrate, our Birmingham Nissan dealership is proud to have numerous Frontier lease offers and finance specials available. After all, we’re where the sale never ends!

If you need an affordable truck without all the frills, now’s your chance to bring home one of the cheapest and most dependable mid-size pickups in the country. Shop our selection of 2019 Frontier models for sale in Birmingham today! Contact Jim Burke Nissan at (205) 588-6287 to speak with our sales team and schedule a test drive. Our Birmingham truck dealership is located near Hoover, AL, and everyone here would be privileged to welcome you to our Nissan family.

Sources & Photos: